Andrew Wakefield and Measles Vaccinations

Andrew Wakefield and Measles Vaccinations

Everybody Knows

Most people know that Andrew Wakefield falsified data from his measles vaccines studies and that his 1998 article on autism and gastrointestinal disease was retracted by The Lancet as it deceitfully showed that a link between measles vaccines and autism. 1

Everyone knows that the link with vaccination and autism has been thoroughly discredited. However, as a result of Wakefield’s discredited research, parents still believe in the link between autism and vaccination and as a result millions of children are denied life-saving vaccinations by irresponsible parents.

Wakefield subsequently had his licence to practice medicine in the UK revoked.

Biography

Andrew Wakefield received his medical degree from St. Mary’s Hospital Medical School, which is part of the University of London, in 1981. He specialised in gastrointestinal surgery and inflammatory bowel disease. He qualified as Fellow of the Royal College of Surgeons in 1985. He has published over 140 scientific articles. 64 2

Previous Studies Related to Measles Vaccination

A paper published in 1995 reached the following conclusion. 3

Prevalences of Crohn’s disease, ulcerative colitis, coeliac disease, and peptic ulceration were determined in 3545 people who had received live measles vaccine in 1964 as part of a measles vaccine trial. A longitudinal birth cohort of 11407 subjects was one unvaccinated comparison cohort, and 2541 partners of those vaccinated was another.

Compared with the birth cohort, the relative risk of developing Crohn’s disease in the vaccinated group was 3·01 (95% Cl 1·45-6·23) and of developing ulcerative colitis was 2·53 (1·15-5·58). There was no significant difference between these two groups in coeliac disease prevalence.

What Really Happened

In the early 1990s, Dr. Wakefield began to study a possible link between the measles virus and bowel disease. He published a 1993 study, Evidence of persistent measles virus infection in Crohn’s disease 65 4

Wakefield co-authored a 1995 article published in The Lancet, Is measles vaccine a risk factor for inflammatory bowel disease? 66 5

On February 28, 1998, Wakefield and 12 colleagues published a paper in the Lancet, as an Early Report. The paper described the clinical findings in 12 children with chronic enterocolitis and severe regressive developmental disorder.

The children, aged between 3 to 10, were referred to a paediatric gastroenterology unit headed by Professor John Walker-Smith, with a history of normal development followed by loss of acquired skills, including language, together with diarrhoea and abdominal pain.

Professor Walker-Smith, one of the world’s leading pediatric gastroenterologists and senior author of The Lancet paper, wrote in 1997 that,

[These children] have not had the level of investigation which we would regard as adequate for a child presenting with such a devastating condition.

The parents (not Wakefield or the other 12 authors) associated the behavioural changes with measles, mumps and rubella [MMR] vaccination in eight of the 12 children, with measles infection in one child, and otitis media [middle ear inflammation] in another.

It was later revealed that the parents who indicated otitis media also associated the changes with MMR vaccination. Because of the hostility it caused when discussing their child’s condition with the medical profession, they decided not to mention vaccination.

The conslusion that Wakefield’s 1998 paper raised the issue of developmental behavioral concerns resulting in the scare campaign is clearly false as the parents decided not to mention vaccination prior to visiting Wakefield.

The conclusion of the paper was that the,

Associated gastrointestinal disease and developmental regression in a group of previously normal children, which was generally associated in time with possible environmental triggers.

News Conference

Prior to the publication of the paper in The Lancet on 28th February 1998, Wakefield raised concerns regarding the safety of the MMR vaccine.

He compiled a 250 page report and as a result concluded that,

I cannot support the continued use of the polyvalent MMR [measles, mumps, rubella] vaccine. I have no doubt of the value of the continued use of the monovalent vaccines, and will continue to support their use until the case has been proven one way or another of the measles link to chronic inflammatory bowel disease.

This was announced at a press conference prior to the paper’s publication. The UK government withdraw the licence to use single vaccines six months later in September.

Recall that MMR vaccine containing the Urabe strain of mumps virus had already been withdrawn in 1992 following serious safety concerns in Japan and Canada because it caused meningitis.

The editor of The Lancet, Richard Horton, asked that the authors issue a partial retraction of the interpretation that MMR vaccine causes autism.

However, the paper did not make that conclusion. Autism is not mentioned in the paper.

Three of the 13 authors said no.

The Charges Against Wakefield by the General Medical Council

The General Medicine Council (GMC) made the following charges against Wakefield. 67

  • Dr. Wakefield was paid 55,000 British pound sterling (about US $90,000) by litigators for the study published in The Lancet, and he failed to disclose this conflict of interest;
  • He and his colleagues performed medically unnecessary tests on the children in the 1998 study and lacked appropriate ethical clearances;
  • The children in the 1998 study were selected for litigation purposes (as described in the Sunday Times article) and not referred by local physicians; and
  • He drew blood from children at his son’s birthday party for control samples in the 1998 study with callous disregard for the distress that this might cause children.

At no stage was there any allegations by the GMC that data has been fabricated.

Falsification of Data

The ony data included in the paper was results for vitamin B12 and urinary methylmalonic acid [MMA]. Inflammatory bowel disease and Crohn’s disease has been associated with vitamin b12 [cobalamin]. MMA is a more reliable test for the determining the status of vitamin B12. 6

It was a journalist Brian Deer who first suggested that the data was fabricated six years after the article was published. Apparently it escaped the attention of all other including the parents, co-authors, the medical department, reviewers and readers.

Not even the General Medical Council who bought the charges of malpractice against Wakefield and the two other authors who refused to retract their findings because “there was nothing to retract”.

Failure to Disclose Payment from Litigators

Dr. Wakefield accepted 55,000 pounds to conduct a study for the class action suit regarding vaccines and autism. This was a research grant from which Dr. Wakefield personally received no compensation. Dr. Wakefield did not start this study until after the case series for the Lancet 12 had been submitted.

Legal documents prove that Dr. Wakefield’s hospital knew about this study and knew about the amount of money he received, most of which went to pay the salary of a designated laboratory technician. Documents further demonstrate that Dr. Wakefield disclosed in a national newspaper over one year before publication of the 1998 article that he was working with the litigators.

Horton, editor of The Lancet, had been informed and was aware of Dr. Wakefield’s role in the vaccine-related litigation before the publication of the 1998 article.

Medical Necessity and Ethical Clearances

The Lancet 12 were very unwell.

Each child was administered tests with the intent to aid that child. The hospital administration was fully aware of the tests being conducted and made no objections. Because all of the tests were “clinically indicated” and not for research purposes, no ethical clearance beyond what Prof. Walker Smith already possessed was required. Notably, no patient, parent, or guardian has ever made accusations against Dr. Wakefield or testified against him for ethical violations or medically unnecessary procedures. Dr. Wakefield and his colleagues rejected the GMC’s ruling that the tests for the Lancet 12 were unnecessary.

The Lancet 12’s Referrals

The General Medical Council charged that the children were referred through the litigation effort and not through ordinary medical channels. This is incorrect. Parents started contacting Dr. Wakefield long before the litigation started, and independently of it. Since the litigation study was not yet started by the time The Lancet study was completed and submitted to the journal, this finding is false. Dr. Wakefield and his colleagues reject that claim; the families contacted them directly because of their medical expertise.

Control Blood Samples from a Child’s Birthday Party

Dr. Wakefield arranged for control blood samples from healthy, typically developing children to be taken at his son’s birthday party. Most of the children’s parents were medical colleagues and friends. He did this with the children’s and parents’ fully informed consent and gave the children 5 pounds each for their trouble. The procedure was undertaken by an appropriately qualified doctor using a standard technique. The children were happy to be helpful and went on to enjoy the birthday party.

Retraction of the 1998 Lancet Article

The Lancet published the following retraction on 2nd February 2010.

Following the judgement of the UK General Medical Council’s Fitness to Practise Panel on Jan 28, 2010, it has become clear that several elements of the 1998 paper by Wakefield et al1 are incorrect, contrary to the findings of an earlier investigation. In particular, the claims in the original paper that children were “consecutively referred” and that investigations were “approved” by the local ethics committee have been proven to be false. Therefore we fully retract this paper from the published record. 68

In the High Court case that exonerated John Walker-Smith, Justice Mitting ruled that the Lancet children were consecutively referred and that medical procedures used in the study, including lumbar punctures and endoscopic biopsies, were clinically indicated and therefore did not require approval from an ethics committee.

A statement by The Royal Free and University College Medical School and The Royal Free Hampstead NHS Trust

The Vice-Dean and campus director of Royal Free and University College School, Professor Humphrey Hodgson, wrote to The Lancet editors in 2004 stating:

We are entirely satisfied that the investigations performed on the children reported in the Lancet paper had been subjected to appropriate and rigorous ethical scrutiny. Because the nature of the condition affecting child behaviour and gastroenterological symptoms was unknown and required elucidation, the investigation of these children was properly submitted to and fully discussed by the Ethical Practices Committee at the Royal Free Hampstead in 1996. 69

The editors rejected this review by the campus director of the medical school where the children were treated. They found another reviewer that rejected the above review without giving any explanations on the reasons.

The hypothesis that the inability of the intestines to absorb nutrients, in particular, vitamin B12, vitamin C and folate may contribute to the severity of the symptoms of the 12 patients being treated.

These dietary interventions help in treating inflammatory bowel disease and subsequently did provide substantial help when given the opportunity. 7 ~ 8 ~ 9

The High Court Ruling

Professor John Walker-Smith contested each and every finding made by the General Medical Council in the High Court. Justice John Mitting, overturned all of the panel’s findings with respect to Walker-Smith.

Justice Mitting concluded that the panel made “fundamental errors,” “distorted evidence” and based its findings on an inadequate analysis of the facts. GMC provided “inadequate and superficial reasoning and explanation for its conclusions”, “inappropriately rejected evidence”, relied upon “flawed” and “wrong” reasoning and made “numerous and significant inadequacies” in its conclusions.

Justice Mitting described the panel’s findings as “not legitimate,” “perverse,” “odd”, “wrong,” “unsustainable,” and “untenable.”

Justice Mitting ruled that the Lancet children were consecutively referred and that medical procedures used in the study, including lumbar punctures and endoscopic biopsies, were clinically indicated and therefore did not require approval from an ethics committee.

Table 1
ChildAge (years)SexAbnormal laboratory testsEndoscopic findingsHistological findings
14MHb 10·8, PCV 0·36, WBC 16·6 (neutrophilia), lymphocytes 1·8, ALP 166
Ileum not intubated; aphthoid ulcer in rectum
Acute caecal cryptitis and chronic non-specific colitis
29.5MHb 10·7LNH of T ileum and colon; patchy loss of vascular pattern; caecal aphthoid ulcer Acute and chronic non-specific colitis: reactive ileal lymphoid hyperplasia
37MMCV 74, platelets 474, eosinophils 2·68, IgE 114, IgG1 8·4LNH of T ileumAcute and chronic non-specific colitis: reactive ileal and colonic lymphoid hyperplasia
410MIgE 69, IgG1 8·25, IgG4 1·006, ALP 474, AST 50LNH of T ileum; loss of vascular pattern in rectum
Chronic non-specific colitis: reactive ileal and colonic lymphoid hyperplasia
58MLNH of T lieum; proctitis with loss of vascular patternChronic non-specific colitis: reactive ileal lymphoid hyperplasia
65MPlatelets 480, ALP 207LNH of T ileum; loss of colonic vascular patternAcute and chronic non-specific colitis: reactive ileal lymphoid hyperplasia
73MHb 9·4, WBC 17·2 (neutrophilia), ESR 16, IgA 0·7LNH of T ileumNormal
83.5FIgA 0·5, IgG 7Prominent ileal lymph nodesAcute and chronic non-specific colitis: reactive ileal lymphoid hyperplasia
96MLNH of T ileum; patchy erythema at hepatic flexureChronic non-specific colitis: reactive ileal and colonic lymphoid hyperplasia
104MIgG1 9·0LNH of T ileum and colonChronic non-specific colitis: reactive ileal lymphoid hyperplasia
116MHb 11·2, IgA 0·26, IgM 3·4LNH of T ileumChronic non-specific colitis
127MIgA 0·7LNH on barium follow-through;colonoscopy normal; ileum not intubatedChronic non-specific colitis: reactive colonic lymphoid hyperplasia
LNH=lymphoid nodular hyperplasia; T ileum=terminal ileum. Normal ranges and units: Hb=haemoglobin 11·5–14·5 g/dL; PCV=packed cell volume 0·37–0·45; MCV=mean cell volume 76–100 pg/dL; platelets 140–400 109/L; WBC=white cell count 5·0–15·5 109/L; lymphocytes 2·2–8·6 109/L; eosinophils 0–0·4 109/L; ESR=erythrocyte sedimentation rate 0–15 mm/h; IgG 8–18 g/L; IgG1 3·53–7·25 g/L; IgG4 0·1–0·99 g/L; IgA 0·9–4·5 g/L; IgM 0·6–2·8 g/L; IgE 0–62 g/L; ALP=alkaline phosphatase 35–130 U/L; AST=aspartate transaminase 5–40 U/L.
Table 2Symptom
ChildBehavioural diagnosisExposure identified by parent or doctorInterval from exposure to first behavioural symptomFeatures associated with exposureBehaviourBowel
1AutismMMR1 weekFever / delirium12 monthsNot known
2AutismMMR2 weeksSelf injury13 months20 months
3AutismMMR48 hoursRash and fever14 monthsNot known
4Autism? Disintegrative disorder?MMRMeasles vaccine at 15 months followed by slowing in development.
Dramatic deterioration in behaviour immediately after MMR at 4·5 years
Repetitive behaviour,
self injury,
loss of self-help
4.5 years18 months
5AutismNone - MMR at 16 monthsSelf-injurious behaviour started at
18 months
4 years2 years
6AutismMMR1 weekRash & convulsion; gaze avoidance & self injury15 months19 months
7AutismMMR48 hoursConvulsion, gaze avoidance21 months2.5 years
8Post-vaccinial encephalitis?MMR2 weeksDisinterest; lack of play19 months19 months
9Autistic spectrum disorderRecurrent otitis media1 week (MMR 2 months previously)Fever, rash & vomiting18 months2.5 years
10Post-viral encephalitis?Measles (previously vaccinated with MMR)24 hoursRecurrent “viral pneumonia”for 8 weeks following MMR15 monthsNot known
11AutismMMR1 week15 monthsNot known
12AutismNone - MMR at 15 monthsLoss of speech development and deterioration in language skills noted at 16 monthsNot known

For a much more complete explanation of the events involving the 1998 Lancet paper, read the following book.

Wakefield, A. (2017). Callous Disregard: Autism and Vaccines—The Truth Behind the Tragedy. Skyhorse Publishing.

Last updated on Wednesday 18 November 2026 at 21:20 by administrators

Post Type: page

Footnotes

  1. Wakefield, A. et al. (1998) RETRACTED: Ileal-lymphoid-nodular hyperplasia, non-specific colitis, and pervasive developmental disorder in children. The Lancet. 351 (9103), 637–641.
  2. Wakefield, Andrew J. (2010) Callous Disregard: Autism and Vaccines: The Truth Behind a Tragedy.
  3. Thompson, N. P. et al. (1995) Is measles vaccination a risk factor for inflammatory bowel disease? The Lancet. 345 (8957), 1071–1074.
  4. Wakefield, A. J. et al. (1993) Evidence of persistent measles virus infection in Crohn’s disease. Journal of Medical Virology. 39 (4), 345–353.
  5. Thompson, N. P. et al. (1995) Is measles vaccination a risk factor for inflammatory bowel disease? The Lancet. 345 (8957), 1071–1074.
  6. Wakefield, Andrew J. Callous Disregard: Autism and Vaccines: The Truth Behind a Tragedy Skyhorse Publishing.
  7. Yakut, M. et al. (2010) Serum vitamin B12 and folate status in patients with inflammatory bowel diseases. European Journal of Internal Medicine. 21 (4), 320–323.
  8. Pan, Y. et al. (2017) Associations between Folate and Vitamin B12 Levels and Inflammatory Bowel Disease: A Meta-Analysis. Nutrients. 9 (4), 382.
  9. Akbulut, S. (2022) An assessment of serum vitamin B12 and folate in patients with Crohn’s disease. Medicine. 101 (50), e31892.

Search

Low-carbohydrate Mania: The Fantasies, Delusions, and Myths

Center for Nutrition Studies

Center for Nutrition Studies