Glucose Tolerance – Comparison of High-Fat and High-Carb Diets

Way back in 1927, J.S. Sweeney assigned healthy, young medical students into four dietary groups: 1 2

  • high-carbohydrate diet consisting of sugar, candy, syrup, baked potatoes, bananas, oatmeal, rice and white bread
  • high-fat diet consisting of olive oil, butter, mayonnaise, egg-yolks, and cream
  • high-protein diet consisting of lean meat, lean fish, and egg-whites
  • the fourth group was placed on a fasting regime

The students were fed their diets for two days and a glucose tolerance test was performed on the morning of the third day.

After only two days on their experimental diets, the only group showing a normal, healthy response to the glucose tolerance test was the high-carbohydrate group. Sweeney’s paper states that this diet “possessed a markedly increased tolerance for dextrose” The protein group had slightly impaired glucose tolerance whilst the high-fat and starvation diets showed a marked decrease in their tolerance for sugar.


A graph of the responses to the 4 diets is shown below. The glycemic index is determined by the area under the graph over a 2 hour period.

 

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Footnotes

  1. Sweeney, J. S. (1927) Dietary Factors that Influence the Dextrose Tolerance Test. Archives of Internal Medicine. 40 (6), 818–830.
  2. Sweeney, J. S. (1928) A comparison of the effects of general diets and of standardized diets on tolerance for dextrose. Archives of Internal Medicine. 42 (6), 872–876.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Search

Search Help

WHO’s Recommendations

WHO's recommendations on saturated fat are out of date, expert team says.
However, the study has been funded by the dairy and beef industries.
Discover how industry-funded research is deceiving the public.